Fill-timing challenge / Answer key
Both records saw the same signal.
Only Record B uses a price supplied after the signal became available.
Follow the signal and the simulated fill
Synthetic prices, February 3–10, 2025. Both records model 10 basis points of price cost on one buy. The exercise stops at the first fill and omits separate commissions, taxes and additional market impact.
- Friday, February 7. The three closes were 97, 96, and 100. Their mean was 97.67 to two decimals. The final close of 100 triggered the signal after it became available.
- Record A used the Friday close. Its modeled price of 100.100 includes the assumed cost. The problem is timing. The order would have needed the published final close to decide to buy at that same price.
- Record B used the next supplied open. The Monday, February 10 reference open was 103.00. With the modeled cost, the price is 103.00 × 1.001 = 103.103 per share. This is a simulated fill under the stated assumptions.
A cutoff rerun checks whether later data changes earlier calculations. The fill clock needs its own check even if those calculations match. Daily bars give you reference prices. Order records and market data are needed to verify execution.
Exercise 01 · Version 1 · November 9, 2026